Property Management in Reynoldsburg, Ohio
Full-Service Property Management for Reynoldsburg Investors and Landlords
Looking for reliable property management in Reynoldsburg, Ohio? RL Property Management helps rental property owners – from experienced investors to accidental landlords – get better results with less day-to-day stress. Whether you own a single-family home, a duplex, or a small rental portfolio, we provide full-service management customized to meet your goals.
Reynoldsburg’s affordability, diverse community, and location just east of Columbus make it a popular choice for tenants, especially families and young professionals. While the schools and safety ratings are more mixed than other suburbs, consistent demand and accessible pricing make Reynoldsburg a strategic market for investors looking to balance cash flow with long-term growth.
Headquartered in Columbus, we manage properties across Central Ohio and understand the unique needs of neighborhoods like Reynoldsburg. Our flat-rate pricing, responsive systems, and local expertise ensure your rental stays occupied, compliant, and profitable.
Have a rental property in Reynoldsburg? Schedule a call with our team today.
Map of Reynoldsburg, Ohio
We manage rental properties throughout Reynoldsburg and the greater Columbus metro area.
What’s It Like to Own Rentals in Reynoldsburg, Ohio?
Reynoldsburg continues to attract renters and investors due to its affordability, access to parks and green space, and location just minutes from downtown Columbus. If you’re considering buying or holding rental property in the area, it offers solid potential for long-term cash flow and consistent tenant demand.
🎓 Diverse Educational Opportunities:
Reynoldsburg is served by the Reynoldsburg City School District, which holds a C+ overall rating on Niche. The district is recognized as the most diverse in Ohio, offering a range of programs including STEM academies and college preparatory tracks, appealing to families seeking varied educational paths.
🛡️ Moderate Safety Profile
Hilliard has a C crime and safety rating from Niche. Like many growing suburbs, it sees a mix of lower violent crime and occasional property crime—something to be aware of, but not unusual for metro-adjacent areas.
💸 Affordable Investment Market
The average rent in Reynoldsburg is approximately $1,500/month (Zillow), and the median home price is around $269,900 (Redfin). This affordability, combined with steady demand, makes Reynoldsburg an attractive option for investors seeking reliable cash flow and long-term appreciation.
🏠 Varied Housing Stock
Reynoldsburg offers a mix of housing options, including single-family homes, townhouses, and apartments, catering to a diverse tenant base. The presence of parks, community centers, and shopping areas enhances the appeal for families and young professionals alike.
💼 Proximity to Employment Hubs
Located just east of Columbus, Reynoldsburg provides residents with easy access to major employment centers in the region. The city’s strategic location supports a stable rental market, drawing tenants who work in Columbus but prefer suburban living.
Whether you’re a seasoned investor or new to property management, Reynoldsburg presents a balanced market with opportunities for growth and consistent rental income.
RL Property Management Services for Reynoldsburg Investors
We keep things simple, transparent, and effective, so you get the most from your rental property with less hassle. Below are just a few of the reasons investors choose to work with us: consistent income, fewer surprises, and long-term peace of mind matter.
No Leasing Fees
We don’t charge extra to place tenants. Leasing is included in your monthly management fee, saving you thousands over time—especially for long-term investors or multi-unit owners.
Routine Property Inspections
We conduct quarterly inspections with photos and detailed reports. These proactive check-ins help catch maintenance issues early, reduce tenant damage, and protect your long-term asset value.
Flat-Rate Management Fees
No percentage-based pricing. You pay one consistent, flat monthly fee—no hidden charges, markups, or surprise costs.
Expert Maintenance Coordination
Our in-house maintenance team and 24/7 emergency service line ensure your tenants are taken care of quickly and professionally—without overpaying for basic repairs.
Start Managing Your Reynoldsburg Property the Right Way
Whether you’re self-managing a single home or juggling multiple rentals, we can help you protect your investment, reduce stress, and improve long-term performance. Let’s talk about your rentals in Reynoldsburg—and see if working with a professional property management company is the right move for you.
Ready to Talk Now?
Want to Know What Your Property Could Rent For?
Reynoldsburg, Ohio Resources
“Great place to rent from. Amazing people quick to respond for getting things fixed or questions about the unit. I would rent from them for a long as I can. This should be your first choice.”
~Bobby P
What Our Clients Say About Us
Want to Learn More?
If you’d like to learn more about our properties and what it’s like to work with RL Property Management, get in touch. We’d be happy to talk more about our rental properties, our application requirements, and our leasing process.
RL Property Management
750 Cross Pointe Rd. STE B, Columbus, OH 43230
(614) 725-3059
info@rlpmg.com
Licensed Real Estate Brokerage in the State of OH
*Office Hours By Appointment Only