Property Management in Worthington, Ohio

Full-Service Property Management for Worthington Investors and Landlords

Looking for expert property management in Worthington, Ohio? RL Property Management partners with real estate investors, self-managing landlords, and accidental rental owners to help them earn more while doing less. Whether you own a single-family home, duplex, or small multi-unit property, we deliver full-service management aligned with your long-term investment goals.

Worthington’s highly rated schools, stable home values, and suburban charm make it a competitive rental market, especially for families and professionals seeking quiet neighborhoods with access to downtown Columbus. With most homes receiving multiple offers and strong rental demand, it’s an ideal area for buy-and-hold investors focused on long-term performance.

Based in the Columbus area, RL manages properties throughout the metro and understands the unique character of Worthington and its surrounding neighborhoods. Our local expertise, flat-rate pricing, and proactive systems keep your rental protected, occupied, and profitable—without the headaches of self-management.

Have a rental property in Worthington? Schedule a call with our team today.

Map of Worthington, Ohio

We manage rental properties throughout Worthington and the greater Columbus metro area.

What’s It Like to Own Rentals in Worthington, Ohio?

Worthington continues to attract both renters and long-term investors thanks to its A-rated schools, established neighborhoods, and convenient access to downtown Columbus. With strong demand, steady appreciation, and a well-balanced housing mix, it’s a market well worth considering for anyone looking to buy or hold rental property in central Ohio.

🎓 Top-Rated Schools:

Worthington is served by the Worthington City School District, which holds an A rating on Niche. Its academic reputation attracts families seeking rentals in well-established, family-friendly neighborhoods—making it a strong draw for long-term tenants.

🛡️ Safe & Stable Area

Worthington has a B rating for crime and safety from Niche, indicating a generally safe suburban environment with typically low property crime levels for a metro-adjacent area. It’s considered one of the more stable communities in Franklin County.

💸 Reliable Rental Demand & Home Values

Homes in Worthington rent for an average of $1,500/month (Zillow), and most properties see quick leasing cycles due to high demand. The median home price is around $539,000 (Redfin), reflecting the area’s stability and desirability for buy-and-hold investors.

🏠 Family-Oriented Property Mix

The Worthington rental market is dominated by single-family homes, many located in walkable, tree-lined neighborhoods. A modest mix of townhomes and older apartment communities adds options for smaller households and young professionals.

💼 Steady Job Base Nearby

Major employers such as Hyperion Materials & Technologies, I Am Boundless, and Diamond Innovations provide local economic stability and attract a professional tenant base from both the public and private sectors.

Whether you’re managing one unit or expanding a portfolio, Worthington offers strong fundamentals: consistent demand, solid appreciation, and a community that appeals to long-term renters.

RL Property Management Services for Worthington Rental Owners

Managing rental property doesn’t have to be complicated. Our systems are designed to be clear, proactive, and investor-friendly—so you spend less time worrying and more time earning. Here’s how we help you stay ahead and sleep easier.

No Leasing Fees

We don’t charge extra to place tenants. Leasing is included in your monthly management fee, saving you thousands over time, especially for long-term investors or multi-unit owners.

Routine Property Inspections

We conduct quarterly inspections with photos and detailed reports. These proactive check-ins help catch maintenance issues early, reduce tenant damage, and protect your long-term asset value.

Flat-Rate Management Fees

No percentage-based pricing. You pay one consistent, flat monthly fee—no hidden charges, markups, or surprise costs.

Expert Maintenance Coordination

Our in-house maintenance team and 24/7 emergency service line ensure your tenants are taken care of quickly and professionally—without overpaying for basic repairs.

The Best Option to Manage Your Worthington Investment Property

From single-property owners to experienced investors, we help landlords take the guesswork out of managing rentals and focus on long-term success. Let’s discuss your properties in Worthington and whether our services are the right fit for your goals.

Ready to Talk Now?

Curious How Much Your Property Could Rent For?

{

“Great place to rent from. Amazing people quick to respond for getting things fixed or questions about the unit. I would rent from them for a long as I can. This should be your first choice.”

~Bobby P

The logo for the National Association of Residential Property Managers
The logo for Equal Housing Opportunity, supported by RL Property Management

What Our Clients Say About Us

4.3/5
4.3/5
486 reviews
5 star
375
4 star
33
3 star
1
2 star
12
1 star
65
0 star
0

Google
5.0/5
Oct 8, 2025
Google - Soumaya Taki - RL Property Management Group
Google
5.0/5
Oct 7, 2025
Google - Larry Thomas - RL Property Management Group
Google
1.0/5
Oct 1, 2025
Google - Nicholas Lardas - RL Property Management Group
Absolutely Disgusting Experience – Do Not Rent from RL Property Management This has been one of the worst rental experiences we’ve ever had. We are paying $2,407/month for an apartment in Lewis Center, OH, and what we walked into was absolutely unacceptable. The carpet is filthy — covered in red and yellow stains, and you can tell they tried to clean it with bleach, which only made it worse. It’s still dirty, discolored, and looks like it hasn’t been properly cleaned in years. The walls are damaged, chipped, and even have writing on them. The bathroom has visible mold, and worst of all, the laundry machine is full of mold and completely unusable. They had the nerve to ask us to give them 7 days to make the place “livable” — yet nothing has been done. They promised a cleaning crew, but no one has come. No follow-up, no accountability. Just silence after they got our money. This company is completely unprofessional and shows zero concern for their tenants’ health or basic living standards. We moved across state lines expecting to walk into a clean, safe home — instead, we got a mold-infested, dirty apartment with bleach-stained carpets and broken promises. Avoid RL Property Management at all costs. If you’re considering renting from them, don’t. You’ll regret it.
Google
1.0/5
Oct 1, 2025
Google - Hamdi Omar - RL Property Management Group
WARNING: DO NOT RENT FROM RL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT – UNSAFE, UNSANITARY, UNPROFESSIONAL This has been by far the worst rental experience we’ve ever had. We’re paying $2,407/month for a unit in Lewis Center, OH that is unsafe, filthy, and absolutely unfit to live in. The apartment was disgusting from the moment we arrived: • The carpet is covered in red and yellow stains, partially bleached, but still visibly dirty and disgusting. • The walls are damaged, with chipped paint and writing still visible. • The bathroom has mold, and • The laundry machine is infested with mold and not even usable — a clear health hazard. They told us to give them 7 days to make the place livable. That time has passed, and they’ve done nothing. No cleaners, no maintenance, no follow-up — just excuses and silence. It gets worse: when I went to their office in person to try to get help, they threw me out. Not only did they refuse to take responsibility, but they also treated me with total disrespect — as if I was the problem for expecting the place I’m paying thousands for to be livable. This company is beyond unprofessional. They are negligent, dishonest, and clearly have no regard for tenants’ health, safety, or basic human decency. DO NOT rent from RL Property Management. They will take your money, hand you the keys to a filthy, moldy, unmaintained property, and then disappear when you ask them to fix it. And if you dare to confront them about it — they’ll kick you out of their office. Stay far away. This company is a disgrace.
Google
5.0/5
Sep 26, 2025
Google - Chieffasworld - RL Property Management Group
They take care of business and get right to it thanks Rob k
Google
5.0/5
Sep 24, 2025
Google - Stef A - RL Property Management Group
Key pickup and finalizing everything on move in day was quick & easy thanks to the amazing Natalie! Smoothest move in experience ever! Thank you! 🙂
Google
1.0/5
Sep 23, 2025
Google - Marty DeLaat - RL Property Management Group
As an owner of Single-Family Homes, Duplexes, and Commercial properties across multiple states I found this to be the worst experience I have had with any of the 5+ property management firms I've worked with. Classic bait & switch with tons of hidden costs and ZERO accountability for their errors. The incorrectly stated the amenities and most importantly the LOCATION of the property listing which caused it to sit on the market much longer than it should of. Despite ME finding the error, it took weeks to correct, and they accepted zero accountability for what was obviously their mistake. Don't believe them when they say they treat properties like their own, or that the fee structure is better than other PM companies. They will ticky tack charges at every opportunity. They also had staff turnover which meant we were juggled between multiple points of contact. The fact that no one on their team actually meets with potential tenants is a major shortcoming, NOT a selling point. Just an atrocious experience that cost me thousands of dollars. I would've probably given them a second chance to prove themselves if it wasn't for their lack of professionalism and overall ineptitude. There are far better options in the Columbus area, and I highly advise to go with someone else. Would be a zero-star rating if that was an option.
Google
2.0/5
Sep 17, 2025
Google - Tresa Cervantez - RL Property Management Group
I had high hopes for them because the front end of this experience was great with Sara and she deserves 5 stars for all she did but after the lease was signed seemed things changed. Sara was not as responsive like the beginning and I was just so disappointed😞. maintenance requests were addressed in a timely manner but come to find out they were charging the home owner extensive fees for everything, like 450 for a pvc pipe that was clogged in the HBAC system causing a leak in the basement?! So yesterday my neighbor shows up to inform me the owner wanted us to know that RL no longer is managing this property since 9/11! No word from RL about this until I called them this morning 9/16 and then they send me an email, dating as of today they're no longer managing the property! No courtesy at all! Per the owner not professional either!!
Google
5.0/5
Sep 14, 2025
Google - Rita Distelhorst - RL Property Management Group
I’ve lived in my rental condo for about four years. I’ve had few maintenance issues but the issues I’ve had have been resolved quickly and to my satisfaction. The people who have come to my home to work have been completely courteous and professional.
Google
5.0/5
Sep 12, 2025
Google - jamie lord - RL Property Management Group
Kendra was absolutely amazing to work with! So detailed, patient, and kind for the entire process. She answered all of my questions in detail, very quick to respond and helped me every step of the way! 🙂
Google
5.0/5
Sep 11, 2025
Google - Rulene Dobson - RL Property Management Group
Google
5.0/5
Sep 11, 2025
Google - Stephanie La Stella - RL Property Management Group
Finding a new place can be so stressful but Kendra was amazing and instrumental in helping make things as easy and seamless as possible. I cannot thank Kendra enough for the excellent service, the timely communications, and the peace of mind it all brought! Awesome experience, highly recommend!
Google
5.0/5
Sep 3, 2025
Google - Ashley Flaquer - RL Property Management Group
Kendra Menchavez responded promptly and was so helpful! This has been a very organized and pleasant experience
Google
5.0/5
Aug 29, 2025
Google - Christopher Benhatzel - RL Property Management Group
RL Property Management made the transition from living on our house to renting it out seamless. They offered great insight every step of the Way. The team was prompt with responses to our questions and went above/beyond expectations. We would highly recommend them If you are looking for a property management company.
Google
4.0/5
Aug 27, 2025
Google - Chris Richeson - RL Property Management Group
RL was great during our move, everything last minute across the country when we found this home for rent. They made every accommodation for our urgent and last minute move, thank you!! Communication is good, the home we moved into has a few issues that they're currently resolving to make for a pleasant move-in. They are very strict when it comes to everything YOU as the renter need to do before they'll give you keys. I've always rented from owners instead of management companies so it was a challenge to drive for 25 hours straight through then be told I couldn't get keys into electric and power were setup... so I spent an hour on the phone at the leasing office to setup everything; after an exhausting trip they were less than understanding about that part... Currently they're working to make sure the home is up to snuff and move in ready as advertised; they're doing a great job for the issues that exist. Hopeful that all will get remedied soon before all the rest of my home shows up in containers. The home is nice, as advertised, but was dusty and the counters have some weird slime on them and the faucets spray water everywhere and the front door doesn't close all the way... the garage is so dirty and I'll have to start weeding the lawn ASAP as it's just been let run for a while. Overall RL has been good for the 3 days I've rented from them.
Google
5.0/5
Aug 22, 2025
Google - moubear32 - RL Property Management Group
RL property management has handled my rent account for about a year now. I had my first major incident since living in my house. The water heater was leaking causing flooding into the drain and on the basement floor. I called RL property management and they immediately sent out a plumber to look at the problem. The plumber said that the water heater was now bad and I thought, oh no! How much is this gonna cost me. RL property management had the plumber take out the old water heater and install a new one and never charged me a dime. Thanks RL property management.
Google
5.0/5
Aug 18, 2025
Google - Naima Khalif - RL Property Management Group
“The leasing team was very professional, helpful, and quick to respond to all my questions. They made the entire process smooth and easy. I highly recommend them!”
Google
5.0/5
Aug 15, 2025
Google - Sharon Martin - RL Property Management Group
Google
5.0/5
Aug 13, 2025
Google - Margaret OBrien - RL Property Management Group
Kendra has been extremely helpful, kind, and prompt in answering any and all questions in the leasing process! It is relieving to have what can sometimes be a stressful process made clear and uncomplicated.
Google
5.0/5
Aug 11, 2025
Google - Iola Duncan - RL Property Management Group
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Exceptional Service from Kendra at RL Property Management Kendra has been nothing short of amazing to work with. From the very first interaction, she demonstrated professionalism, kindness, and a genuine commitment to helping me every step of the way. She communicates clearly, responds quickly, and always makes sure I feel informed and supported. It’s rare to find someone who combines efficiency with such a warm, personable approach. RL Property Management is lucky to have her, and I truly appreciate all the effort she puts into making the process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommended!
Google
5.0/5
Aug 5, 2025
Google - Julie Aho - RL Property Management Group
5+ Stars to the leasing team at RL Property Management! In a city where most rentals are managed by BOTs/automated systems, I greatly appreciated the leasing team personally showing me their properties. Their process is efficient. More home owners should use them for property management. Thank you so much Kendra and team!
Google
5.0/5
Jul 31, 2025
Google - Rochelle Dyer - RL Property Management Group
Great process from beginning to end with Kendra and her team! Would highly recommend!
Google
2.0/5
Jul 31, 2025
Google - Erika Tarawallie (Erika) - RL Property Management Group
We had a beeping noise in our home and it took them a week to have someone come and resolve the issue . I was in direct communication with Alex and it seemed as though they did not take my concern seriously at all. Additionally they were inconsistent with getting the grass cut. And there were multiple times people came to do work in or outside of our home and we were given no notice.
Google
1.0/5
Jul 31, 2025
Google - Emmanuela Slobodyanyuk - RL Property Management Group
Worst management company, I have been with a few and this one has to be the most rudest company that don’t not take care of the renters needs and request! The call center is the disrespectful and don’t care if you are living in dangerous living conditions, if you want to rent a home don’t go through this company save the headache and mental health
Google
1.0/5
Jul 29, 2025
Google - Char Williams - RL Property Management Group
This company has to be the most unprofessional company that I know, They sent me a message at 7 PM today saying that my Landscaping was overgrown, and that they will send someone out in 14 days to resolve this issue. Please tell me where my landscaping is overgrown? Please show me photos and supporting evidence of overgrown landscaping. Now my neighbor next-door is absolutely a problem, However, I keep my landscaping cut weekly. So to receive a message like this and paying this company almost $3000 a month to rent, has taken me to the next level. Do your job and verify before disrupting unproblematic tenants!
Google
5.0/5
Jul 25, 2025
Google - Kirsten Winston - RL Property Management Group
Very easy and pleasant to work with! Loved the timely responses.
Google
5.0/5
Jul 22, 2025
Google - Haley Hedges - RL Property Management Group
Love that they helped talk me though every step and let me know when and how to do something, communicated thoroughly step by step every question that needed to be answered, super kind and informative!
Google
5.0/5
Jul 18, 2025
Google - Wayne Crutcher - RL Property Management Group
This was my first experience with tree trimmer. They did an amazing job and understanding clean up. They explained the one they couldn't because it was on an electric line and aep will get that. Excellent experience all around. Thank you, the Crutcher family. 5 star service
Google
5.0/5
Jul 11, 2025
Google - Ayla Finley - RL Property Management Group
Application went smooth and quickly compared to other applications. I’ve been a tenant for a couple years and never had any issues!
Google
5.0/5
Jul 11, 2025
Google - Denita Lowery - RL Property Management Group
Very nice to deal with.truely work with me

Want to Learn More?

If you’d like to learn more about our properties and what it’s like to work with RL Property Management, get in touch. We’d be happy to talk more about our rental properties, our application requirements, and our leasing process.

 

 

RL Property Management

750 Cross Pointe Rd. STE B, Columbus, OH 43230
(614) 725-3059
info@rlpmg.com
Licensed Real Estate Brokerage in the State of OH

*Office Hours By Appointment Only