Columbus, Ohio, continues to present a promising yet evolving landscape for investors in the single-family housing market. With a growing population, shifting market dynamics, and significant development projects underway, the city offers opportunities for those willing to adapt to a maturing and increasingly competitive market. This guide examines the current market status and outlook for investors considering Columbus as a potential investment hub.

Click here to download PDF version.

What’s the Current State of Columbus’s Single-Family Housing Market?

According to local Realtors, the Columbus single-family housing market has recently experienced an increase in inventory, reaching a two-month supply—the highest in six years. This shift reflects a return to a more balanced market following the competitive frenzy of the pandemic years when homes often sold within days. As interest rates remain elevated, the rapid pace of sales has slowed, allowing homes to remain on the market longer, with the average days on market now closer to 25.

While increased inventory could indicate more options for buyers, the market remains dynamic, with median prices continuing to climb. Currently, the median sales price in Columbus is approximately $324,000, marking a year-over-year increase of 4%. Higher interest rates are encouraging price adjustments, and list-to-sale price ratios have softened slightly, with a 0.7% discount at closing. These shifts create a more favorable environment for investors, particularly during the slower fall and winter months when competition is lower.

Which Columbus Neighborhoods Are Attracting the Most Investor Interest?

Neighborhood preferences among investors are gravitating toward affordable suburbs and emerging corridors that offer better growth prospects. Suburban areas around Columbus are particularly popular, providing newer housing stock and less maintenance, as well as more affordable price points and taxes.

• Affordable Growth Areas: The southern suburbs, including Lancaster and communities in the Teays Valley School District, are drawing interest due to larger plots of land and lower taxes. These areas also boast strong school districts, making them ideal for family-oriented tenants, while still being affordable compared to Columbus’s core neighborhoods.
• Emerging Urban and Suburban Corridors: The Morse and 161 corridors, located east of I-71 and inside the 270 loop, offer an entry point for first-time investors due to their affordable housing stock and vibrant communities. Although these neighborhoods may lack the upscale amenities of other suburbs, their proximity to the city and affordability make them appealing for long-term growth.
• Higher-Tax Areas with Established Demand: Affluent suburbs like Dublin, Powell, and New Albany remain popular with homebuyers, but high acquisition costs and property taxes may limit cash flow potential for investors. For those focused on rental yield, nearby areas like Grove City and Commercial Point provide a balance of affordability and stable rental demand, offering solid investment opportunities.

How Are Population and Demographic Shifts Impacting Columbus’s Housing Market?

In contrast to other Ohio cities, Columbus’s population is growing steadily, attracting a diverse array of residents, from young professionals to remote workers and families. This population influx is largely driven by economic opportunities and a desirable suburban lifestyle, positioning Columbus as an outlier in a state with generally stagnant growth.

This growth trend extends beyond Columbus’s city limits into nearby counties, including Delaware, Union, and Licking, creating a ripple effect in the housing market. Proximity to Columbus’s employment centers and convenient access to major highways have made these suburbs increasingly attractive to newcomers. This demographic expansion, coupled with steady job growth, ensures sustained demand for single-family housing.

What Impact Are Zoning and Policy Changes Having on Single-Family Homes?

Columbus recently overhauled its zoning code for the first time in 70 years, signaling a significant shift toward higher-density and mixed-use developments along major corridors. While these zoning changes primarily target commercial and multifamily developments, they are likely to boost neighborhood appeal and amenities over time, indirectly benefiting nearby single-family properties. Investors might find enhanced long-term value in areas where these zoning changes support growth.

Additionally, some pro-tenant policies have emerged, increasing regulatory pressures on landlords. Many suburbs have placed restrictions on short-term rentals, potentially limiting opportunities for investors interested in Airbnb or similar models. In affluent school districts like Dublin and Upper Arlington, high property taxes further challenge cash-flow-driven investments. Investors need to stay informed on local policies and regulations as Columbus continues adapting to its population growth and housing needs.

How Are Major Developments and Infrastructure Projects Shaping Buyer Interest?

Significant developments, particularly the Intel project near New Albany, are set to impact Columbus’s housing market profoundly, though progress on this project has been slower than initially anticipated. As the Intel manufacturing plant nears completion, nearby communities like Johnstown, Newark, and Pataskala stand to gain considerable interest from investors, though competition is expected to increase, and property prices have already surged in anticipation.

Meanwhile, other large corporations, including Amazon, Microsoft, and Honda, are expanding in Columbus, sustaining strong employment levels and creating long-term demand for single-family housing. Upcoming infrastructure improvements, such as highway expansions and a proposed 270 loop, are expected to further increase accessibility and attractiveness for surrounding areas, potentially boosting property values in communities located along these new routes.

Is Columbus’s Housing Market Facing Affordability and Supply Challenges?

Despite an increase in inventory, affordability remains a challenge in Columbus. Rising home prices have pushed many first-time buyers to the outskirts of the city, where more affordable properties are available. The median home price of $324,000 limits options for budget-conscious buyers and investors seeking properties in established neighborhoods.

For investors, rising construction costs and market demand make it difficult to find budget-friendly properties with immediate cash flow. However, areas on the city’s periphery, such as Reynoldsburg and Pickerington, offer more affordable entry points. Although these areas may not deliver high cash flow upfront, they are positioned for future appreciation as Columbus’s population and rental demand increase.

In some neighborhoods, it may even be cheaper to rent than to buy, a trend that creates demand for rental housing. Investors focusing on cash flow might consider southern suburbs with lower property taxes and affordable housing stock, providing better margins in the current market environment.

What Lies Ahead for Columbus’s Single-Family Housing Market?

The Columbus single-family housing market holds strong potential for investors with a long-term focus. As the city expands its suburban model with walkable downtowns and community spaces, new residents are increasingly drawn to areas offering these amenities. This suburban development approach, combined with Columbus’s steady job growth and strong school districts, supports a resilient investment environment.

Looking forward, neighborhoods on the periphery of Columbus, particularly Lancaster and Teays Valley School District, appear well-positioned for growth. Affordable and attractive to young families, these areas provide promising opportunities for early investment as population density rises and new amenities emerge.

While the pace of appreciation may not match the post-pandemic boom, Columbus’s strategic growth and proactive zoning improvements create a favorable climate for single-family investors. For those prepared to hold properties and adapt to Columbus’s evolving market dynamics, the region remains a safe and profitable choice for single-family investment.

Conclusion

Columbus’s single-family housing market is full of opportunities, but it comes with its own set of challenges. With zoning updates, big corporate investments, and a growing population, the city is primed for continued growth. For investors willing to branch out into up-and-coming areas and stay on top of local regulations, the potential for long-term value is huge.

If you’re looking for help managing your rental property or navigating the Columbus market, RL Property Management has you covered. Reach out today—we’d love to talk about how we can make managing your investment easier and more profitable.